Mailbag: Adam Jones, Manny and More...

Believe it or not, people send me emails. I know… I was surprised too. With a Fantasy Baseball season that’s seen as much parody as this one I can see why people are in need of help. The combination of injuries, underperformers, highly anticipated call ups and of course the Manny saga have made this season about as hard to predict as which mood your wife or girlfriend is going to be in after the Grey’s Anatomy season finale. Seriously, your guess is as good as mine. While you’re pondering the endless possibilities, let’s take a look at a few emails: Question: I, like many others in the fantasy baseball world, have possession of Manny Ramirez. I know initially it seems like one has no choice but to stash him for his return, but is this really true? Is it worth saving Ramirez until his return, or will I be better off moving on? -George Coffee, Toledo, OH. George, my friend, this is an easy one. You definitely keep Manny. The only scenario I could see dropping him is if you have no bench spots at all. If you end up dropping him, someone else is going to grab him immediately. Then, when he comes back on July 3rd and blows up you’ll feel like Britney Spears watching Justin Timberlake’s “Behind the Music”. Remember, 50 games sounds like a lot more than it is. He is out for May and June. You still have the entire second-half of the season to enjoy his production. I expect him to come back with something to prove. If last year’s second-half stint with the Dodgers showed us anything, it’s that when he’s got something to prove, Manny is going to prove it. Hi, PCBScout, my High School buddies and I have been in a keeper league for 4 years now. As is the case with most groups of friends, people move out of the hometown and all over the country. We have most of our guys on the East Coast, with a handful on the West Coast. I'm wondering - do you see any advantages or disadvantages, regarding roster moves, waivers, etc., between the coasts? Thanks! -Vaughn Blevins, Yonkers, NY. Hi Vaughn, I know the feeling. A few of my friends are still here in town, but we’ve also lost a few soldiers to the lure of better weather, better pay and more entertainment options. Hard to imagine, huh? This particular question is one I had to think about for a while. I’ve come to the conclusion that ownership is the same on either coast, but might have a slight advantage on the East Coast over the West for a few minor reasons. Most games are played on the east coast, which means you have access to watching more games. Also, for weekend games that start at 1 pm EST, you’re more likely to be up and available to manage your roster before those games get underway. Other than that, I can’t think of an advantage to one coast over the other. Good question, V.B.! - Paul, I am writing in about Tampa Bay Rays Minor League pitcher David Price. I have had Price since the beginning of the season and have been offered a couple of trades for low to medium level outfielders and or pitchers. I have held out in hopes that Price will turn out to be something as special as he is predicted to be. Should I get rid of him and move on, or is he worth holding in hopes he gets called up soon? –JR K, Rochester, NY. JR, I know waiting on a guy to get called up can be frustrating. It seems like all the information you can get is speculation and meanwhile that roster spot is giving you as much production as a Pontiac plant (too soon?). That being said, I think you’re going to see Price in the majors soon. Right now his numbers are not looking very impressive in the minors. He is 1-4 with a 4.60 ERA. The good news is his strikeout numbers are still very impressive at over 8 K’s per nine innings. Also in Price’s favor is that the Rays can’t be pleased with what they are getting from Jeff Niemann, their current fifth starter. Niemann has an ERA over 5 and has only made it through 6 innings once this year. In addition to the numbers the Rays are approaching a pivotal spot in their season. They’re 6.5 games back and if they don’t start to get in to stride they’re going to be out of it before they know it. As for whether or not to trade Price; that depends. Of course if you can fill a need, or get a great value from an over-anxious owner, do it. For the low to medium level players you indicated, don’t bother. PCB, being from Aberdeen, MD, I am obviously a huge Orioles fan! I have loved the maturation of Adam Jones. He is off to a hot start (.358, 6 HR, 21 RBI, 33 R, 3 SB) and has been extremely valuable to my team. However, I have reservations that he might just be off to a fluke start and will cool down throughout the year. Although, I do not want to trade him, do you think now is the time to shop him around the league while his stock is high and get a top tier performer the rest of the year, or do you think he has arrived and should be kept? I am not in a keeper league, so next year does not matter to me. Go IRONBIRDS! –Skip, Aberdeen, MD Skip, congrats on having Adam Jones to root for. He is quite a talent. This note was clearly sent before Jones put up another 2 Homeruns on Tuesday. Our buddy Skip must have been trying to keep his Markakis in his shorts over that one. I don’t think there is any question that Jones will cool down some. He’s on pace for some absolutely staggering numbers, and while he’s very talented and I am a big fan, he will certainly face some growing pains along the way. The answer to should you trade any player is always the same; for the right price, yes! Never stop trying to make your team better. No one on your roster should ever be untouchable. With that said, I think the chances are pretty slim that you’ll get proper value for Jones. You might have some prospect crazed owner willing to part with top talent to get his claws on Jones, but most likely people are going to be offering you 3rd tier type players for Jones at this juncture. Just to give you a few names to work with, I would probably be looking for a Morneau level hitter or Gallardo level pitcher for Jones. Anything less than that range is not giving you proper reliability in exchange for the production and upside you’d be losing with Jones. Thanks for the emails, everyone and keep them coming! PCB Scout Questions? Comments? Random nonsense? Email me: pcbscout(at)gmail.com